From Siesta Key to the north, to the Island of Venice to the south, Casey Key is a narrow secluded 8-mile barrier island of unspoiled natural beauty, private pristine beaches and abundant wildlife. No stoplights and no high rises offer visitors and residents alike the pleasure to enjoy the unspoiled natural bounty and beaches, recreational opportunities, along with local restaurants offering the fresh catch from the gulf, cocktails and entertainment.
Residential options of Casey Key range from historic bungalow, and simple cottages, to impressive modern architecture and massive beach to bay estates where anonymity is possible. The sense of “old Florida” remains on this small stretch, that at times feels as though you’re traveling on a private drive. The mainland in Nokomis is home to the historic Spanish Point, the Oscar Scherer State Park and the very popular Legacy Bike Trail spanning from Venice to Sarasota.
Residents and visitors are drawn to this pristine location for its abundant natural beauty. Lush landscape and private gated entries offer an element of privacy to the homes and famous residents of Casey Key.
Accessible by two bridges, Casey Key offers a convenience to shopping, dining, restaurants, recreational amenities along with access to a private airport in Venice and the cultural amenities of Sarasota.
Search Casey Key Homes for Sale
Below you will find all current real estate listings in Casey Key, Florida. Contact us to schedule a showing, or if you have any questions. Create an account with us to save your favorite Casey Key listings and receive email notifications when new properties become available.
Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.